🦄 Bash vs. MCP - token efficient coding agent tooling
In this conversation, Dex and Vaibhav delve into the intricacies of coding agents, focusing on the debate between using MCP (Model Control Protocol) and Bash for tool integration. They explore the importance of understanding context windows, token management, and the efficiency of using different tools. The discussion emphasizes the significance of naming conventions, dynamic context engineering, and the engineering efforts required to optimize performance. They also share real-world applications, best practices for using MCPs, and engage with the community through a Q&A session.
Project Details
Open in GitHub🦄 ai that works: Bash vs. MCP - Token Efficient Coding Agent Tooling
In this episode, Dex and Vaibhav delve into the intricacies of coding agents, focusing on the debate between using MCP (Model Control Protocol) and Bash for tool integration, exploring context windows, token management, and optimization strategies.
Links:
Episode Overview
This episode explores the fundamental trade-offs between using Bash and MCP (Model Control Protocol) for coding agent tool integration. The hosts demonstrate real-world examples comparing token usage, examine the impact on context windows, and share advanced techniques for optimizing coding agent performance.
Key Topics Covered
- Token efficiency and the downsides of JSON in tool definitions
- Understanding context windows and their impact on model accuracy
- Writing your own drop-in replacements for MCP tools
- Naming conventions and their critical role in model outputs
- Dynamic context engineering techniques
- Advanced tricks like .shims for forcing uv instead of python or bun instead of npm
- Real-world applications and performance optimizations
- Best practices for using MCPs effectively
Whiteboards
Key Takeaways
- There is no one-size-fits-all solution in coding agents - choose tools based on your specific needs
- Understanding the underlying mechanics of models and context management is crucial for effective use
- The accuracy of results can be significantly impacted by how you manage context
- MCP tools can simplify integration for those unfamiliar with APIs, but come with token overhead
- Dynamic context engineering can enhance the performance of coding agents
- Naming conventions play a critical role in the accuracy of model outputs
- Efficient token usage is essential for maximizing context window effectiveness
- Real-world applications demonstrate the practical implications of these concepts
- Flexibility in tool usage allows for better customization and performance
- Community engagement and feedback are vital for continuous improvement
All Episodes
Anthropic Post Mortem
In August, Anthropic experienced a bunch of interesting bugs and wrote up a really cool postmortem about it. On this episode, we'll go deep into the problems they hit and why they happened. https://www.anthropic.com/engineering/a-postmortem-of-three-recent-issues
Dynamic Schemas
In this episode, Dex and Vaibhav explore the concept of dynamic UIs and how to build systems that can adapt to unknown data structures. They discuss the importance of dynamic schema generation, meta programming with LLMs, and the potential for creating dynamic React components. The conversation also delves into the execution and rendering of these dynamic schemas, highlighting the challenges and opportunities in this evolving field. They conclude with thoughts on future directions and the importance of building robust workflows around schema management.
Evals for Classification
In this episode of AI That Works, hosts Vaibhav Gupta and Dex, along with guest Kevin Gregory, explore the intricacies of building AI systems that are ready for production. They discuss the concept of dynamic UIs, the challenges of large-scale classification, and the importance of user experience in AI applications. The conversation delves into the use of LLMs for enhancing classification systems, the evaluation and tuning of these systems, and the subjective nature of what constitutes a 'correct' classification. The episode emphasizes the need for engineers to focus on accuracy and user experience while navigating the complexities of AI engineering. The speakers also discuss model upgrades, user feedback, and the importance of building effective user interfaces, emphasizing iterative development and rapid prototyping for chatbot performance evaluation.
Generative UIs and Structured Streaming
We'll explore hard problems in building rich UIs that rely on streaming data from LLMs. ​Specifically, we'll talk through techniques for rendering **STRUCTURED** outputs from LLMs, with real-world examples of how to handle partially-streamed outputs over incomplete JSON data. We'll explore advanced needs like * Fields that should be required for stream to start * ​Rendering React Components with partial data ​* Handling nullable fields vs. yet-to-be-streamed fields * ​Building high-quality User feedback * ​Handling errors mid-stream
Voice Agents and Supervisor Threading
Exploring voice-based AI agents and supervisor threading patterns for managing complex conversational workflows.
Claude for Non-Code Tasks
On #17 we talked about advanced context engineering workflows for using Claude code to work in complex codebases. This week, we're gonna get a little weird with it, and show off a bunch of ways you can use Claude Code as a generic agent to handle non-coding tasks. We'll learn things like: Skipping the MCP and having claude write its own scripts to interact with external systems, Creating internal knowledge graphs with markdown files, How to blend agentic retrieval and search with deterministic context packing
Interruptible Agents
Anyone can build a chatbot, but the user experience is what truly sets it apart. Can you cancel a message? Can you queue commands while it's busy? How finely can you steer the agent? We'll explore these questions and code a solution together.
Decoding Context Engineering Lessons from Manus
A few weeks ago, the Manus team published an excellent paper on context engineering. It covered KV Cache, Hot-swapping tools with custom samplers, and a ton of other cool techniques. On this week's episode, we'll dive deep on the manus Article and put some of the advice into practice, exploring how a deep understanding of models and inference can help you to get the most out of today's LLMs.
Context Engineering for Coding Agents
By popular demand, AI That Works #17 will dive deep on a new kind of context engineering: managing research, specs, and planning to get the most of coding agents and coding CLIs. You've heard people bragging about spending thousands/mo on Claude Code, maxing out Amp limits, and much more. Now Dex and Vaibhav are gonna share some tips and tricks for pushing AI coding tools to their absolute limits, while still shipping well-tested, bug-free code. This isn't vibe-coding, this is something completely different.
Evaluating Prompts Across Models
AI That Works #16 will be a super-practical deep dive into real-world examples and techniques for evaluating a single prompt against multiple models. While this is a commonly heralded use case for Evals, e.g. 'how do we know if the new model is better' / 'how do we know if the new model breaks anything', there's not a ton of practical examples out there for real-world use cases.
PDFs, Multimodality, Vision Models
Dive deep into practical PDF processing techniques for AI applications. We'll explore how to extract, parse, and leverage PDF content effectively in your AI workflows, tackling common challenges like layout preservation, table extraction, and multi-modal content handling.
Implementing Decaying-Resolution Memory
Last week on #13, we did a conceptual deep dive on context engineering and memory - this week, we're going to jump right into the weeds and implement a version of Decaying-Resolution Memory that you can pick up and apply to your AI Agents today. For this episode, you'll probably want to check out episode #13 in the session listing to get caught up on DRM and why its worth building from scratch.
Building AI with Memory & Context
How do we build agents that can remember past conversations and learn over time? We'll explore memory and context engineering techniques to create AI systems that maintain state across interactions.
Boosting AI Output Quality
This week's session was a bit meta! We explored 'Boosting AI Output Quality' by building the very AI pipeline that generated this email from our Zoom recording. The real breakthrough: separating extraction from polishing for high-quality AI generation.
Building an AI Content Pipeline
Content creation involves a lot of manual work - uploading videos, sending emails, and other follow-up tasks that are easy to drop. We'll build an agent that integrates YouTube, email, GitHub and human-in-the-loop to fully automate the AI that Works content pipeline, handling all the repetitive work while maintaining quality.
Entity Resolution: Extraction, Deduping, and Enriching
Disambiguating many ways of naming the same thing (companies, skills, etc.) - from entity extraction to resolution to deduping. We'll explore breaking problems into extraction → resolution → enrichment stages, scaling with two-stage designs, and building async workflows with human-in-loop patterns for production entity resolution systems.
Cracking the Prompting Interview
Ready to level up your prompting skills? Join us for a deep dive into advanced prompting techniques that separate good prompt engineers from great ones. We'll cover systematic prompt design, testing tools / inner loops, and tackle real-world prompting challenges. Perfect prep for becoming a more effective AI engineer.
Humans as Tools: Async Agents and Durable Execution
Agents are great, but for the most accuracy-sensitive scenarios, we some times want a human in the loop. Today we'll discuss techniques for how to make this possible. We'll dive deep into concepts from our 4/22 session on 12-factor agents and extend them to handle asynchronous operations where agents need to contact humans for help, feedback, or approvals across a variety of channels.
12-factor agents: selecting from thousands of MCP tools
MCP is only as great as your ability to pick the right tools. We'll dive into showing how to leverage MCP servers and accurately use the right ones when only a few have actually relevant tools.
Policy to Prompt: Evaluating w/ the Enron Emails Dataset
One of the most common problems in AI engineering is looking at a set of policies/rules and evaluating evidence to determine if the rules were followed. In this session we'll explore turning policies into prompts and pipelines to evaluate which emails in the massive Enron email dataset violated SEC and Sarbanes-Oxley regulations.
Designing Evals
Minimalist and high-performance testing/evals for LLM applications. Stay tuned for our season 2 kickoff topic on testing and evaluation strategies.
Twelve Factor Agents
Learn how to build production-ready AI agents using the twelve-factor methodology. We'll cover the core concepts and build a real agent from scratch.
Code Generation with Small Models
Large models can do a lot, but so can small models. We'll discuss techniques for how to leverage extremely small models for generating diffs and making changes in complete codebases.
Reasoning Models vs Reasoning Prompts
Models can reason but you can also reason within a prompt. Which technique wins out when and why? We'll find out by adding reasoning to an existing movie chat agent.
Large Scale Classification
LLMs are great at classification from 5, 10, maybe even 50 categories. But how do we deal with situations when we have over 1000? Perhaps it's an ever changing list of categories?